Two views on union certification changes | Opinion

By Ben Stewart

The BC Liberals have been elevating the alarm over the NDP’s adjustments to employee rights over the previous month, particularly Invoice 10 and their determination to take away the key poll. This can be a plan of action that will probably be dangerous for B.C. for thus many causes, together with:

— The key poll system is a basic democratic proper — the NDP’s Invoice 10 will scrap this honest and democratic course of employees presently use to determine the way to manage themselves.

— Beneath the present secret poll system at the moment, there are strict pointers that shield workers from undue coercion or strain by employers or union organizers.

— Whereas the NDP declare Invoice 10 will guarantee a good unionization course of, union organizers will probably be unrestricted as to the place, when and the way usually they’ll method employees to get signatures on playing cards — they’ll even be free to gather signatures in social settings and within the presence of different co-workers.

— The NDP’s personal 2018 Labour Relations Code Evaluate Panel Report really helpful protecting the key poll — the NDP ignored that recommendation and plans to scrap the key poll anyway.

— A latest ballot confirmed 79% of British Columbians oppose casting off the key poll and solely 9% assist card checks — Invoice 10 ignores well-liked opinion and is a significant step backwards for B.C.

— The NDP sees this as a solution to increase membership in NDP-aligned unions, that are their largest donors — let’s keep in mind, the NDP obtained the most important donation ($672,576) in B.C.’s political historical past from the United Steelworkers Union earlier than the 2017 election.

— For 30 of the previous 38 years, B.C. has operated underneath the key poll system and it’s the norm in different provinces all through Canada.

— Beneath the NDP, insider labour agreements are already costing taxpayers tons of of tens of millions of extra {dollars} in value overruns on initiatives just like the Pattullo Bridge substitute and Kicking Horse Canyon — it’s estimated that NDP-friendly labour agreements might add as a lot as $4.8 billion to the price of public infrastructure initiatives.

— Invoice 10 may even enable for ‘union raiding’ within the building business each summer season, which can result in additional delays and price overruns on vital residential, business, and public infrastructure initiatives.

— It’s extremely hypocritical that essentially the most secretive authorities in Canada needs to strip employees of their proper to a secret poll — it seems to be just like the NDP expects full transparency from everybody however themselves.

Ben Stewart is the MLA for Kelowna West

——

By Alex Hemingway

The B.C. authorities lately launched laws that can enable a majority of employees in a office to arrange a union a little bit extra simply, making it tougher for employers to intimidate and intervene in organizing drives. That’s excellent news each for working folks and for the standard of our democracy.

If handed, Invoice 10, the Labour Relations Code Modification Act, will enact a single-step certification course of — one thing that’s already in place in jurisdictions like Quebec, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and federally regulated workplaces.

Single-step certification merely signifies that if a transparent majority of employees in a office again forming a union—and signal authorization playing cards declaring this—they’re allowed to kind one. That is truly a return to the standard framework for union certification in Canada. 

The one-step course of was the norm till the Eighties when governments started rolling it again in lots of provinces, instituting a two-step course of. After a majority of employees had signed union authorization playing cards, a second step was added requiring a reconfirmation vote to be held. This may sound innocuous (if pointless), however the principle impact was to provide employers a window to run anti-union campaigns and intimidate employees into abandoning organizing drives.

Employer interference campaigns sometimes embody techniques like holding “captive viewers conferences” (necessary anti-union conferences), sending regular streams of textual content messages and posting anti-union messaging across the office, hiring consultants who specialise in union-busting efforts and easily firing the employees who’re most energetic within the organizing effort.

Sadly, these kind of practices are widespread. They’ve been getting considerably extra media consideration lately throughout an ongoing wave of employee organizing drives at giant companies like Amazon and Starbucks in the USA. However the identical techniques are used right here in Canada at companies like Amazon, Starbucks and Tim Hortons, and in lots of lesser-known companies all through varied sectors as confirmed by BC’s Labour Relations Board.

The return to single-step certification gained’t imply the top of aggressive anti-union campaigns, however it’s going to make them considerably harder to hold out by lowering a key window of time for employer interference. Throughout jurisdictions, the principle impact (and sure purpose) of a two-step certification course of was all the time to cut back unionization charges. Analysis analyzing BC and different jurisdictions exhibits this discount in unionization is precisely what occurs.

Strengthening the precise of employees to arrange unions has broader implications for tackling excessive inequality and creating extra democratic management over our politics. Unions assist offset a crucial imbalance of energy that exists between employees and house owners in a capitalist financial system. It’s more and more clear that the wealthy wield disproportionate affect over politics throughout the developed world. However a rising physique of empirical analysis means that greater unionization charges may also help cut back these persistent political inequalities.

As my very own doctoral analysis and different evaluation has discovered, working-class persons are severely underrepresented among the many holders of legislative workplace. However this too could be modified. The place unionization charges are greater, employees usually tend to maintain public workplace.

Strengthening the precise to unionize is important not solely to employees in search of to boost their wages and enhance their working situations, but additionally to tackling inequality and restoring some working-class affect over our usually corporate-dominated politics. By eradicating one barrier to forming unions and blunting the impact of employer anti-union campaigns, the return to single-step union certification is a win for employees in BC.

Alex Hemingway is the CCPA-BC’s senior economist.