The 30-year struggle for abortion access in P.E.I. shows how hard this fight can be

This column is an opinion by Rebecca Viau, who helped lead the combat for abortion entry on Prince Edward Island. For extra details about CBC’s Opinion part, please see the FAQ.

I’ve been on the entrance line of P.E.I.’s combat for abortion entry. I noticed firsthand the hurt accomplished when entry to abortion is proscribed or restricted.

In 2014, I had stepped ahead within the motion and have become a beacon of types, a public face for folks to connect with. As soon as somebody related with me looking for to entry abortion providers, I’d mobilize the community-organized assist community that would assist them discover the therapy they wanted in a well timed method. As a result of abortion providers weren’t accessible on P.E.I. till 2017, anybody looking for an abortion needed to journey off-Island for therapy.

By this expertise, I bore witness to many complicated and sometimes painful conditions that individuals turned trapped in resulting from restricted and restricted entry to abortion. I used to be compelled to share these tales with the general public. Unjustly politicized, the dialogue round abortion was typically too shortly dehumanized and I needed to assist shift the dialog.

By the web site The Sovereign Uterus, I collected and revealed the tales of people that sought to entry an abortion on P.E.I. The web site made an influence. Over 100,000 folks visited the positioning within the first month it was revealed — and other people had been speaking about it. Conversations had been shifting as folks got here to witness the hurt being attributable to the provincial authorities’s refusal to offer entry to abortion on the Island. 

Why did it take 30 years?

Regardless of the shift in public opinion, with the vast majority of Islanders in assist of offering abortion providers on Island, the lawmakers made excuses or skirted the difficulty at each alternative. P.E.I.’s 30-year prohibition on abortion providers wouldn’t be lifted.

In response to the province, Islanders had been pleased with the established order and no adjustments to abortion entry had been wanted. In the long run it was a authorized battle between the community-led group Abortion Entry Now P.E.I. (AAN PEI)  and the Authorities of P.E.I.  AAN PEI sued the federal government for infringing on Islanders’ constitutional proper to equal entry to health-care providers.

Within the spring of 2016, three months after the discover was filed and earlier than the authorized case went to courtroom, the P.E.I. authorities ended its restrictive abortion coverage. The province acknowledged that the courts would have doubtless discovered that their abortion coverage violated the constitution, and introduced they’d open a ladies’s well being clinic and supply a full complement of reproductive well being providers together with medical and surgical abortion.

And sure, all of that did occur.

Nevertheless, what I discover to be of specific be aware is that even with public assist — even with proof of hurt accomplished — it nonetheless took 30 years for the provincial legislation to alter. Neither stress from the federal authorities nor public opinion may persuade P.E.I. to offer equitable entry to abortion. It took 30 years of tireless effort, waves upon waves of effort, from neighborhood activists to not solely strategize a authorized battle however to assist cut back the dangerous impacts of the prohibition by supporting the people who required abortion providers by way of numerous unofficial assist networks. 

Decriminalization would not equal entry

Contemplating Roe v. Wade being threatened in the USA, I really feel it’s important for me to inform this story, and alert others that restrictive and prohibitive legal guidelines usually are not simply modified. And even when abortion has been decriminalized, it would not robotically imply that entry to the providers are equally accessible to all those that require it.

The dialog in Canada needs to be about growing entry to abortion and reproductive providers somewhat than questioning if the service needs to be supplied in any respect. Canada decriminalized abortion in 1988, and I for one am prepared for the main target of the dialogue to shift. It’s not a debate whether or not or not now we have the proper to decide on, and constantly bringing the dialog again to that determined level retains the shortage of entry to abortion on this nation hidden, silenced and cloaked as a political wedge. 

Decriminalization has not led to equitable and even reasonably-improved entry to abortion in Canada, even 30 years after the legislation was modified.

Right now, the vast majority of abortion suppliers on this nation are positioned lower than 150 kilometres from our southern border. And typically only one in six hospitals offer abortion services. Which means many individuals who have to entry this important service are required to navigate a fancy and sometimes troublesome journey to entry this time-sensitive process. In a rustic as huge as Canada, you’d assume that such a fundamental, but life-saving medical process that requires little or no specialised tools could be mobilized in as many communities as attainable.

However the combat for entry continues.

Atlantic Canada would not have true entry

The 2016 UN Human Rights Commissioners Report clearly highlighted the alarming lack of access to abortion services in Canada. The UN known as on the Canadian authorities to take motion on the inequality.

And as entry to abortion is as soon as once more thrust into the information, it has turn into clear that the Canadian authorities has been silently ignoring the truth that our health-care system is failing most individuals who require an abortion on this nation. Regardless of how loudly our leaders declare on the nationwide stage that Canadians have the proper to decide on, that an individual’s proper to decide on is not going to be denied on this nation, the actual fact stays that the provinces management and determine how and the place abortion providers are supplied.

We solely should look to New Brunswick to see how that is taking part in out in the present day.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau himself has said, even on this previous week, that the federal authorities is raring to extend funding to New Brunswick to assist the non-public abortion clinic, Clinic 554, in Fredericton. But regardless of the federal authorities’s promised monetary assist, New Brunswick continues to disclaim entry to abortion by way of the non-public clinic and ignores the hurt being accomplished to not solely the folks in N.B., however to everybody on the East Coast who would profit from elevated entry if the clinic had been to be open for service.

At the moment there are solely 4 hospitals in Atlantic Canada that present abortion providers. That’s 4 clinics with hospitals to offer abortion providers for probably one million folks. This implies not solely the associated fee and stress of travelling, but it surely additionally means longer wait instances and in some circumstances time runs out. 

It is our constitutional proper

If the federal authorities is telling the reality once they say they’re dedicated to supporting the proper to equitable entry to abortion providers on this nation, however the provinces management the supply of the service, what might be the work-around? Positive the federal authorities may put stress on the provinces financially for not offering ample entry to abortion providers, however that’s doubtless too politically messy contemplating our four-year election cycle, and it has confirmed unsuccessful prior to now.

I for one am actually not holding my breath to see any grand strikes by the federal authorities on this means. Nevertheless, I do know that it’s actually attainable for the federal authorities to make contraception and contraceptives free to everybody. Think about the distinction that will make. Actually, take a minute and give it some thought. Let’s begin supporting ladies and gender-diverse Canadians with ample sexual and reproductive well being care from the start. Put money into hurt discount.

I urge everybody who reads this to take the time to go to The Sovereign Uterus web site, to learn and bear witness to the tales of the individuals who survived accessing an abortion on P.E.I. in the course of the prohibition.

Take a second to replicate on the place you slot in this story. Are you feeling complacent in regards to the problem? Is it troublesome to debate with buddies, household and colleagues? Allow us to all take a second to carry area for individuals who have suffered, and open our hearts and minds to the hurt that can proceed to occur if entry stays as restricted as it’s now. Can we shift the dialog to 1 that will probably be productive? I need to proceed to pivot the deal with abortion in Canada from the proper to decide on, to the proper to equitable entry to service. It’s our constitutional proper. 

Curious about writing a First Particular person or Opinion piece for CBC P.E.I.?

We’re on the lookout for submissions from Islanders, or these with a robust connection to the Island, who’ve a compelling private narrative or need to share their tackle a difficulty affecting their neighborhood. You do not have to be an expert author — first-time contributors are at all times welcome.

E mail us your story at pitchpei@cbc.ca. 

For extra info on First Particular person and Opinion submissions see our FAQ.