Why decriminalizing drug possession won’t fix Canada’s toxic supply
That is an excerpt from Second Opinion, CBC Well being’s weekly well being and medical science publication. If you have not subscribed but, you are able to do that by clicking here.
Canada’s poisonous drug provide drawback cannot be fastened by decriminalizing the possession of small portions of medicine alone — a transfer that advocates say is a step in the best course however a far cry from addressing the worsening overdose disaster.
In response to the disaster, the federal authorities introduced a plan this week to permit adults in British Columbia to possess small quantities of some illicit medicine — as much as 2.5 grams of opioids, cocaine, methamphetamine and MDMA inside British Columbia.
However prior to now decade, the illicit drug provide has gone from unthinkably dangerous to unimaginably worse as fentanyl has utterly overtaken heroin and much more harmful medicine have entered the availability.
Since 2016, 26,690 Canadians have died from suspected opioid overdoses, and in B.C. alone there have been 2,224 suspected overdose deaths in 2021 and greater than 9,400 since 2016 — the leading cause of unnatural deaths within the province.
“Nobody is aware of, nobody can know, what they’re promoting or what they’re placing of their our bodies,” Karen Ward, a drug consumer and advocate in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, advised CBC Information in a latest interview.
“I do not even wish to take into consideration how a lot worse it may get.”
7,000% rise in fentanyl in final decade
The dramatic rise of fentanyl in Canada has been stark. In 2012, solely 217 of the road drug samples seized by regulation enforcement companies throughout Canada examined optimistic for fentanyl. In 2021 that quantity grew to over 16,000 samples — a rise of greater than 7,000 per cent.
Of the greater than 24,000 opioid medicine seized by regulation enforcement companies throughout Canada final yr, 72 per cent contained fentanyl or fentanyl analogues, in addition to 45 per cent of the heroin samples confiscated.
However on the similar time, the precise quantity of heroin in Canada fell by greater than 60 per cent over 5 years as fentanyl took over — resulting in an unpredictable and harmful provide.
“Lots of people speak concerning the heroin provide being contaminated with fentanyl, however we have not had heroin provide for a very long time — the availability is fentanyl,” Nick Boyce, director of the Ontario Hurt Discount Community, stated in a latest interview.
“You do not know what dosing you may get and there is many various fentanyl analogues on the market, some that are stronger than others.”
Carfentanil specifically is likely one of the most harmful opioids within the drug provide: 100 occasions extra poisonous than fentanyl, 10,000 occasions extra poisonous than morphine and undetectable by sight, odor or style. And after declining in 2019, it is now on the rise in Canada once more.
The statistics are compiled by Well being Canada’s Drug Analysis Service (DAS), which assessments roughly 125,000 samples of medicine apprehended by the Canada Border Companies Company, the Correctional Service of Canada and police forces throughout the nation every year.
And whereas it merely offers a snapshot of the disaster, it additionally paints a tragic image, one which concurrently exhibits the disappearance of heroin as fentanyl and different harmful opioids contaminated the availability whereas the variety of overdose deaths skyrocketed.
“It is a scary state of affairs — it is just like the properly was poisoned,” stated Ward. “This complete group is simply falling aside as a result of so many individuals have died.”
WATCH | Combating an opioid overdose epidemic throughout a pandemic:
The opioid disaster was an issue in British Columbia earlier than the COVID-19 pandemic, however mixed with an unsafe drug provide and fewer protected injection websites, the disaster has change into an overdose epidemic.
Within the first yr of the pandemic alone, there was a 95 per cent enhance in suspected opioid-related deaths, with 7,224 lives misplaced in Canada, in comparison with 3,711 in 2019.
“That is the worst public well being disaster we have ever seen with regard to poisonous medicine within the historical past of our nation,” stated Donald MacPherson, govt director of the Canadian Drug Coverage Coalition, a coverage advocacy group made up of about 50 organizations.
“Now we have by no means seen something like this earlier than.”
Decriminalization will not have ‘big affect’
However the federal authorities’s decriminalization plan would not come into impact for one more seven months and falls wanting the 4.5 gram threshold that the province and hurt discount advocates referred to as for — an quantity that many critics already believed was too low.
“If that is meant to make sufficient of a distinction to save lots of lives, why does it not take impact for one more seven months?” Ward stated in response to the announcement, including that it does little to handle the poisonous provide of medicine in Canada.
WATCH | Small-scale illicit drug possession decriminalized in B.C.:
The federal authorities has granted an exemption that may see the decriminalization of small-scale possession of sure illicit medicine in B.C. The exemption comes into impact in 2023.
MacPherson stated that whereas the announcement “alerts the course that we have to go” as a rustic, it ought to have been rolled out at a nationwide degree so as to make an actual affect in Canada provided that the overdose disaster is not only a B.C. drawback.
“That is discriminatory, when you reside in one other province, you are probably not going to have the advantages of this mannequin. It is for B.C. residents solely, in order that’s disappointing,” he stated.
“And it is actually not going to have a huge effect on the poisonous drug provide — that’s the primary drawback.”
The federal authorities has signalled it’s open to discussing increasing the scope of decriminalization past simply B.C. to different provinces and cities throughout the nation, however Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Nova Scotia already stated they will not be subsequent in line.
Kayla DeMong, govt director of Prairie Hurt Discount in Saskatoon, stated that whereas decriminalization overcomes a century of “extremely discriminatory” drug coverage, it falls wanting addressing the overdose disaster in a significant means.
“Do I believe it should have a huge effect on our poisonous drug provide? No,” she advised CBC Information. “What I do hope is that it’ll present higher help and sources and fewer legal enforcement for those who use substances.”
Focus must be on poisonous provide: advocates
MacPherson stated that whereas some drug customers in B.C. who’re stopped by police with small quantities of medicine will profit from the decriminalization transfer, police already do not arrest many individuals for possession in Vancouver and it seemingly will not result in main adjustments there.
“It additionally means we will be spending the subsequent seven months placing collectively a mannequin of a coverage change that basically is not concerning the poisonous drug provide,” he stated. “So the main focus of the response is within the incorrect place.”
Advocates have been calling for a protected and controlled drug provide for many years so as to allow individuals who use medicine to entry regulated substances, equivalent to medical-grade heroin, from a authorized supply, fairly than doubtlessly poisonous variations from the illicit market.
“There’s a lot a lot extra to do within the space of giving folks options to the poisonous drug market that’s not taking place — that is the place the true disaster is,” MacPherson stated.
“That form of motion wants to begin taking place, and together with decriminalization that might make sense. However decriminalization by itself? When over 90 per cent of people that die are dying from drug toxicity? That must be handled.”
Ward stated till the poisonous drug provide difficulty is addressed head on in Canada, individuals who use medicine will proceed to die at an unfathomable charge.
“The issue is they don’t seem to be unlawful as a result of they’re harmful, they’re harmful as a result of they’re unlawful,” Ward stated.
“Individuals are dying. I am stunned I am nonetheless alive. Individuals are falling aside. We have been by way of a lot. They’ve suffered a lot, and so they’ve been poisoned to demise by the coverage that we have determined to not change.”
